that's just nightmare for completists
![Totalloco](https://ravinganddrooling.com/core/images/smilies/New_totalloco.png)
everybody knows that David Gilmour likes to make at least small changes to each his releases
so for example :
David Gilmour Live In Gdansk has at least 5 versions - CD (21 tracks) + vinyl (22 tracks) + video (16 tracks) + 90-min theatrical (14 tracks) + 60-min digital (9 tracks)
David Gilmour Live At Pompeii - also 5 versions - CD (21 tracks) + vinyl (21 tracks with some alternate crossfades) + video (21 tracks with alternate track order) + 100-min theatrical (14 tracks) + 60-min digital (9 tracks)
etc.
they do the same with the later years releases of Pink Floyd
Delicate Sound Of Thunder has at least nine different versions - CD (14 tracks) + vinyl (13 tracks) + video (16 tracks) + alternate video (15 tracks) + 45-min digital video (8 tracks) + revised video (16 + 4 tracks) + 90-min digital revised video (14 tracks) - updated CD (22 tracks) + updated vinyl (22 tracks with some alternate crossfades)
and of course this also applies to legendary P.U.L.S.E.
I know 12 of its incarnations - including 9 of them is a video of the actual concert on October 20 1994 at Earls Court
let's stop at them - they are :
1 - 1994 - Original Live Broadcast - 22 tracks
2 - 1994 – Pay Per View Broadcast - 22 tracks - video and audio has minor differences
3 - 1995 - Original VHS Release - 22 tracks - video and audio has alternate minor differences
4 - 1995 - Special LaseDisc Release - 22 tracks - video and audio has same as VHS differences + alternate track order
5 - 2005 - Original DVD Release - 22 tracks - video has more differences and audio is remastered
6 - 2006 - 47-min Arte Concert Digital Broadcast - 10 tracks (TDSOTM performance excerpt only) - has some edits in final announcement and applause
7 - 2019 - TLY (or Revised DVD) Release - 22 tracks - video completely revised - audio is the same as 2005 remastered and has very minor differences (but Any Colour You Like audio is misplaced by not remastered version)
8 - 2020 - 90-min Digital Broadcast - 15 tracлs (TDSOTM + Sorrow + Keep Talking + High Hopes + WYWH + CN) video and audio is the same as TLY version but has some crossfade differences during encores
9 - 2020 - 60-min Russian TV Broadcast - 12 tracks (TDSOTM + Sorrow + Keep Talking) video and audio generally is the same as 90-min Digital Broadcast version but has many edits and differences in On The Run Money Sorrow And Keep Talking
60-min Russian TV Broadcast version is worth paying special attention to - this is the only version subject to significant editing of tracks :
On The Run - cut to 2:30 vs original 3:45 - has a lot of edits
Money - cut to 7:50 vs 8:35 - has some edits
Sorrow - cut to 9:45 vs 11:10 - has some edits
Keep Talking - cut to 7:30 vs 7:35 - has minor edits at the beginning and some edits in final applause and announcement
this 60-min version was broadcast June 14 2020 by Russia TV Channel "Kultura" - and later repeated October 9 2021 and again January 8 2022
https://vk.com/video-85393518_456243516
![Click image for larger version
Name: Pulse-Kultura-09.jpg
Views: 587
Size: 99.9 KB
ID: 367041](filedata/fetch?id=367041&d=1710330995&type=medium)
it's hard to tell who did the editing - but all the credits are there - including the Eagle Vision logo
the titles of the tracks were made by the Russians of course - they as usual mixed everything up - Breath became as Speak To Me - Speak To Me itself and Any Colour You Like remained without titles at all - Any Colour You Like title was placed before Brain Damage - Brain Damage before Sorrow and Eclipse before Keep Talking
![Click image for larger version
Name: Pulse-Kultura-05.jpg
Views: 572
Size: 219.7 KB
ID: 367043](filedata/fetch?id=367043&d=1710331409&type=medium)
![Click image for larger version
Name: Pulse-Kultura-06.jpg
Views: 541
Size: 247.1 KB
ID: 367044](filedata/fetch?id=367044&d=1710331439&type=medium)
I have not heard any information about the broadcast of such 60-min version in any other countries
that's all folks
but - I don’t have this video - I only saw it during the broadcast
now stay with this
![Totalloco](https://ravinganddrooling.com/core/images/smilies/New_totalloco.png)
everybody knows that David Gilmour likes to make at least small changes to each his releases
so for example :
David Gilmour Live In Gdansk has at least 5 versions - CD (21 tracks) + vinyl (22 tracks) + video (16 tracks) + 90-min theatrical (14 tracks) + 60-min digital (9 tracks)
David Gilmour Live At Pompeii - also 5 versions - CD (21 tracks) + vinyl (21 tracks with some alternate crossfades) + video (21 tracks with alternate track order) + 100-min theatrical (14 tracks) + 60-min digital (9 tracks)
etc.
they do the same with the later years releases of Pink Floyd
Delicate Sound Of Thunder has at least nine different versions - CD (14 tracks) + vinyl (13 tracks) + video (16 tracks) + alternate video (15 tracks) + 45-min digital video (8 tracks) + revised video (16 + 4 tracks) + 90-min digital revised video (14 tracks) - updated CD (22 tracks) + updated vinyl (22 tracks with some alternate crossfades)
and of course this also applies to legendary P.U.L.S.E.
I know 12 of its incarnations - including 9 of them is a video of the actual concert on October 20 1994 at Earls Court
let's stop at them - they are :
1 - 1994 - Original Live Broadcast - 22 tracks
2 - 1994 – Pay Per View Broadcast - 22 tracks - video and audio has minor differences
3 - 1995 - Original VHS Release - 22 tracks - video and audio has alternate minor differences
4 - 1995 - Special LaseDisc Release - 22 tracks - video and audio has same as VHS differences + alternate track order
5 - 2005 - Original DVD Release - 22 tracks - video has more differences and audio is remastered
6 - 2006 - 47-min Arte Concert Digital Broadcast - 10 tracks (TDSOTM performance excerpt only) - has some edits in final announcement and applause
7 - 2019 - TLY (or Revised DVD) Release - 22 tracks - video completely revised - audio is the same as 2005 remastered and has very minor differences (but Any Colour You Like audio is misplaced by not remastered version)
8 - 2020 - 90-min Digital Broadcast - 15 tracлs (TDSOTM + Sorrow + Keep Talking + High Hopes + WYWH + CN) video and audio is the same as TLY version but has some crossfade differences during encores
9 - 2020 - 60-min Russian TV Broadcast - 12 tracks (TDSOTM + Sorrow + Keep Talking) video and audio generally is the same as 90-min Digital Broadcast version but has many edits and differences in On The Run Money Sorrow And Keep Talking
60-min Russian TV Broadcast version is worth paying special attention to - this is the only version subject to significant editing of tracks :
On The Run - cut to 2:30 vs original 3:45 - has a lot of edits
Money - cut to 7:50 vs 8:35 - has some edits
Sorrow - cut to 9:45 vs 11:10 - has some edits
Keep Talking - cut to 7:30 vs 7:35 - has minor edits at the beginning and some edits in final applause and announcement
this 60-min version was broadcast June 14 2020 by Russia TV Channel "Kultura" - and later repeated October 9 2021 and again January 8 2022
https://vk.com/video-85393518_456243516
it's hard to tell who did the editing - but all the credits are there - including the Eagle Vision logo
the titles of the tracks were made by the Russians of course - they as usual mixed everything up - Breath became as Speak To Me - Speak To Me itself and Any Colour You Like remained without titles at all - Any Colour You Like title was placed before Brain Damage - Brain Damage before Sorrow and Eclipse before Keep Talking
I have not heard any information about the broadcast of such 60-min version in any other countries
that's all folks
but - I don’t have this video - I only saw it during the broadcast
now stay with this
![Totalloco](https://ravinganddrooling.com/core/images/smilies/New_totalloco.png)
Comment