Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How many versions is enough? (Poll)

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 1
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous template Next
    #1

    How many versions is enough? (Poll)

    With the recent Dark Side of the Moon 50th celebration(?) release, the question is:

    How many studio versions of Dark Side do you own?

    Each CD, cassette, vinyl, 8-track, reel-to-reel, etc counts. Bonus points for some other really odd-ball format.
    64
    0 -1 (Liar)
    15.63%
    10
    2 - 4 (i thought this was the Genesis forum)
    25.00%
    16
    5 - 7 (are you really a PF fan?)
    3.13%
    2
    8 - 11 ( just an average R&D member)
    35.94%
    23
    12 - 15 (now we're getting somewhere)
    7.81%
    5
    16 - 20 (it's like Pokemon, gotta catch them all)
    3.13%
    2
    21 - 30 (I have that half-speed, quadraphonic, MFSL master released only in Sri Lanka)
    6.25%
    4
    30 or more (i might have a problem)
    3.13%
    2
    What's great about America is that everybody has an opinion.... But what's also great, you don't have to listen to 'em. - Dennis Green

    PF - April 18, 1988, Denver
    PF - June 22, 1994, Minneapolis
    Rog - July 16, 2017, Atlanta (Taped)
    Rog - Aug 20, 2022, Atlanta (Taped)
    Nick - March 29, 2019, Atlanta (Taped)
    Tags: None
    #2
    I have 24 in my sorted folders. I may have more that aren't sorted yet.
    Off surfing with Linda, of course...
    • Likes 1

    Comment

      #3
      I have enough to not remember offhand exactly how many. Had to check my Discogs list.

      Comment

        #4
        Fun poll! Clarifying question, is this only physical formats? (do the cassette rips I only have digital copies of count, or no?)
        Roger Waters
        - Las Vegas MGM Grand 2010-11-26
        - Las Vegas T-Mobile Arena 2017-06-16
        - Salt Lake City Vivint Arena 2022-09-08

        David Gilmour
        - Los Angeles Hollywood Bowl 2016-03-25

        Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets
        - Denver Paramount Theatre 2022-10-20​

        Comment

        • MrFender
          #4.1
          MrFender commented
          06-16-2023, 08:50 PM
          Editing a comment
          If they're distinctly different copies, why not? It just adds to all of our collective insanity.
        • CelestialVoices
          #4.2
          CelestialVoices commented
          06-16-2023, 11:07 PM
          Editing a comment
          Okay! Potentially moves me up a tier haha
        #5
        Sorry, why would you want more than one? Surely it’s the music rather than the medium it’s delivered on? I have one copy but I still prefer Tour 72

        Comment

          #6
          I have 46 'rips' on my DSOTM folder, plus the Immersion and Experience on CD and a very old Vynyl which I still conserve because it was the first ever format on which I listened the album for the first time so that makes 49 different 'versions' of the album .
          If an act of empathy is considered somehow as something radical, we're living in dangerous times.

          Pink Floyd tradelist // Oasis tradelist
          • Likes 2

          Comment

            #7
            Click image for larger version Name: image.png Views: 0 Size: 22.0 KB ID: 352975​
            Click image for larger version Name: image.png Views: 0 Size: 13.2 KB ID: 352976
            Some are repeated because they are different rips of the same source I suppose so let's round up to 40 or maybe less.
            Last edited by gotta_be_crazy; 06-17-2023, 12:07 AM.
            If an act of empathy is considered somehow as something radical, we're living in dangerous times.

            Pink Floyd tradelist // Oasis tradelist
            • Likes 7

            Comment

              #8
              Well, i voted 8, because those are the physical ones, but I have like 10 more variations in flac... Maybe I should keep thinning out my collection. That's wholly unnecessary. haha
              • Likes 1

              Comment

                #9
                I voted 12-14, right now the recent 24 bit 96K Stereo Remaster of the 50th is my favorite version. They did a great job on that, the tonality is perfect and while it is not a remix a ton of new details have come out and I like the flow and tone of it.
                • Likes 1

                Comment

                  #10
                  1 (immersion 2011)
                  • Likes 2

                  Comment

                    #11
                    Originally posted by Hallucalation View Post
                    1 (immersion 2011)
                    If you have the 2011 Immersion boxset, then you already own three different studio versions: Stereo, Quad, and 5.1. Actually six, since they are duplicated on the DVD and the Blu-ray... plus the stereo CD that adds up to seven.

                    Comment

                      #12
                      Originally posted by ruben77 View Post

                      If you have the 2011 Immersion boxset, then you already own three different studio versions: Stereo, Quad, and 5.1. Actually six, since they are duplicated on the DVD and the Blu-ray... plus the stereo CD that adds up to seven.
                      Sorry, meant Experience edition. Just 2 CD set (second CD is Wembley show)
                      • Likes 1

                      Comment

                        #13
                        And 9 of WYWH...🤪
                        • Likes 1

                        Comment

                        Previous template Next
                        Working...
                        X